In my personal study I’ve be reading through the travails of Nephi son of Helaman (Helaman 7-11) lately, and really was just struck by the following points, and since it’s good to share:
1) Nephi is accused at one point of personal ambition, that he was seeking to make himself “a great man” (Helaman 9:16) and so had conspired for someone to murder the chief judge. What struck me on this read through is how this may well have seemed outwardly plausible to the people at the time, since Nephi himself had been chief judge (Helaman 3:37, 5:1-4). The circumstances of his abdication might have seemed particularly controversial, for while we learn from 5:4 that he was ‘weary’ of the judgment-seat and undertook to preach the Gospel as Alma had done earlier, the fact that this came in the wake of the Nephites losing half their territory (Helaman 4) and that Nephi appeared to lack political support (5:2-3) may have led many to think Nephi was seeking to reclaim an earlier position of power via other means. And perhaps we too need to be cautious about assuming what appear to be ‘obvious’ motives.
2) The attitude of the five who went to check on the chief judge following Nephi’s prophecy seems important. They didn’t believe Nephi was a prophet, but what I find significant is that they were willing to check and – should it turn out to be correct – expressed the willingness to then believe everything else he had taught (Helaman 9:2). It seemed an illustration of what Alma teaches in Alma 32:27, about how one could “experiment” upon the word and “exercise a particle of faith”. These five didn’t even necessarily “desire to believe”, but they were willing to go and look, and willing to believe all if what they checked was true.
3) The point at which Seantum, the brother and murderer of the chief judge, is accused is very interesting. Nephi tells them precisely what to say, and what Seantum’s replies and reactions will be (Helaman 9:26-36). The actual account of them doing so, however, simply states:
And it came to pass that they went and did, even according as Nephi had said unto them. And behold, the words which he had said were true; for according to the words he did deny; and also according to the words he did confess. (Helaman 9:37)
By giving Nephi’s prophetic instructions in detail, and then not actually giving an account of what happened other than to say it went like Nephi said, I think the passage emphasises the power and accuracy of prophetic fulfilment. It’s saying that Nephi’s prophecy was so accurate, there’s no need to retell it all over again.
4) Finally the section from Helaman 9:39 to 10:1 seems quite ironic. At least some believe Nephi is a prophet (9:40). Others even say “he is a god” (v.41). But amidst all the arguments, even those who claim to believe Nephi “went their ways” and leave Nephi “alone” (Helaman 10:1). That he feels “cast down” (v.3) is quite understandable – even those loudly proclaiming that Nephi is a prophet have wondered off rather than listening to him!